Composting Toilets Comparison


Thinktank toilet allows men to stand and is energy efficient.

The Thinktank toilet allows men to stand and is energy efficient.

There are many composting and waterless toilets on the market. It can be very confusing. The comparison table below will help you compare the main features, and decide which is best for you.

Be a little skeptical about the capacity of some toilets as listed by the manufacturer (listed here where available). In testing we have found toilets that hold far fewer “uses” than advertised. For this reason we show capacity of the solid waste container in gallons whenever possible, alongside the estimated number of uses from the manufacturer.

Some of these waterless / composting toilets are very small and suitable for a van, small RV or boat. The larger toilets are more suitable to a cottage, cabin, or tiny home. You can check measurements on the websites for each toilet.

If you have the space, get a full-sized toilet. The increased capacity is worth a small increase in cost. Less frequent emptying is better!

A few of these toilets drain urine into a bottle. This might be ideal in a van or RV. However, in a stationary location it’s much more convenient to drain the urine into a drain pit, gray water system, or large tank.

Urine bottle for Nature's Head composting toilet

Typical Pee Bottle in small toilet for vans or RVs

There are other differences that were impossible to list in the table below. For example, the general construction of some toilets is far superior to others. Some use very small, inexpensive fans while others use larger, very high quality fans. Some seem to be designed to be difficult (and costly) to repair, while other have ease of repair designed in. Some use absurd plastic hinges that will most certainly break, while others use 1/4″ stainless steel pins. Some include a necessary wall transformer, while others charge up to $50 for it. It’s hard to quantify these things in a table.

Hopefully this will provide a good starting point. We are always available if you have additional questions about comparing composting toilets. Call toll free and talk to a REAL PERSON at 1 888 361 0014.

Note: All these prices are in US dollars. Canadians need to visit the Canadian site here.

Price (Including shipping in the lower 48 states)Men Can StandAirtight
with Air Intake
WarrantyCapacity (estimated solid uses)Fan and VentTrap Door to Conceal WasteRotating waste container to distribute contents and maximize capacity
Thinktank$1199YesYes6 years50-60 uses (7 gallons)YesYesYes
Separett Villa 9215$989NoNo5 years50-60 uses (7 gallons)YesYesYes
Separett Tiny$1049NoNo5 years15 usesYesYesNo
Nature's Head$1065NoNo5 years5 gallonsYesYesNA
Airhead$1130NoNo5 years5 gallonsYesYesNA
Ogo$989NoNo5 years30 uses (5 gallons)YesYesNA
Cuddy$780NoNo2 years15-20 usesYesYesNo
Boxio$229NoNo1 year8-10 usesNoNoNo
Biolet Mini$1250NoNo3 years20 uses (4 gallons)YesYesNo
Trelino$419NoNo2 years6-8 usesNoNoNo